Why do library ebooks have waiting lists?
A popular library ebook has a waiting list because the library licensed a fixed number of copies, and each copy lends to one reader at a time, as a paper book does. Those copies are dear. In figures that the State of Maryland filed in a federal court, a New York Times best seller in December 2020 cost a reader $22.05 as an ebook and cost a library $95.00 (AAP v. Frosh, opinion of 16 February 2022).
One copy, one reader
OverDrive's Libby app says in its help that publishers often require each digital copy to go to one person at a time, and that the library's budget decides how many copies it buys. The trade calls this one copy, one user. Rachel Noorda and Kathi Inman Berens, in a 2023 report that the American Library Association publishes, call OverDrive the dominant player in library ebooks and say libraries typically pay three to four times the consumer price for a licence to a popular title.
The same limit applies when a library lends scans of print books that it owns, one reader per copy, a practice called controlled digital lending. In 2024 a US appeals court ruled that the Internet Archive's version of it wasn't fair use.
Licences that expire
Many of those licences also expire. The report by Noorda and Berens gives an early metered model: from 2011, HarperCollins licensed ebooks to libraries for 26 circulations, after which the licence ended. Penguin Random House moved to licences that expire two years after purchase on 1 October 2018, and lowered its cap on new adult titles from $65 to $55 at the same time. A table in the report, built from OverDrive's data, shows US terms in July 2023: Hachette, Macmillan, Penguin Random House and Simon & Schuster offered ebooks on two-year terms, and HarperCollins on 26 circulations.
So a queue can come back. When a licence runs out, the library pays again or the copy goes. In Libby, a title that has expired shows “Unknown Wait” on the holds shelf, and the library may keep it visible and use the holds to decide whether to buy more copies.
Embargoes and the Maryland law
From 1 November 2019, Macmillan let each library buy a single copy of a new ebook and made it wait eight weeks for more. Macmillan went back to its earlier terms on 17 March 2020, a change that Noorda and Berens tie to the Covid-19 lockdowns.
Maryland tried to change the terms by law. From 1 January 2022, a publisher that licensed an ebook to the public had to offer it to the state's public libraries on reasonable terms. The Association of American Publishers sued, a federal judge blocked the law that February, and on 13 June 2022 the court declared it unconstitutional and unenforceable because the Copyright Act preempts it.
Lending without a queue
Hoopla started a pay-per-use model in 2013, which OverDrive later offered too, according to the same report. The collection a library chooses is open with no waiting, and the library pays each time a patron completes a loan. Noorda and Berens name the drawback: paying per loan is cheap for a book few people borrow and very expensive for one that suddenly becomes popular.
Getting a book sooner in Libby
- Open Shelf > Holds. The estimated wait sits next to each cover, with your place in line and the number of copies in use below the hold.
- If you have a card at a second library, add it. Then tap Available or Unavailable next to a title to see its borrowing options at every library you've added, and place the hold where the list is shortest.
- In Search, turn on the “skip the line” filter under “Catalog Filters”. Skip-the-line copies have no wait list and can't be renewed, and your library may give them a shorter loan.
- When a hold comes in, borrow it within 72 hours, or tap Suspend to keep your place. A suspended hold still moves up the list, and it lapses after 365 days in a row.
- If your library doesn't own the book, save it to a Notify Me smart tag. Where the library offers this, the tag tells it you want the title, and Libby notifies you if the library buys it.