Readwyn 0.1.0

What is social DRM?

Open some DRM-free ebooks and you'll find your own name inside: on a bookplate near the front, in a line at the end of each chapter, or on a notice at the back. That is social DRM. Instead of encrypting the file, the shop marks every copy with details of the person who bought it, in plain sight, hidden in the file, or both, so that a copy found on a file-sharing site leads back to one order. Nothing stops you copying the book or reading it in any app on any device. The mark relies on people not wanting to pass round a file with their name in it, which is the reasoning BooXtream, one of the companies that does the marking, gives on its home page.

Harry Potter, 2011 and 2012

J.K. Rowling kept the digital rights to her books and for years held out against ebook editions. On 23 June 2011 she announced Pottermore, a website that would sell the seven Harry Potter ebooks itself from that October, as The New York Times reported that day. In the Guardian, Sam Jordison picked out the plan for copy protection: no DRM software, but a digital watermark tying each ebook to the identity of its buyer.

October came and went. The ebooks finally went on sale on 27 March 2012, at £4.99 for the first three books and £6.99 for the last four. They worked on the Kindle, the Nook, Sony's Reader and Google Play, but Pottermore was the only place to buy them. The next day Philip Jones of The Bookseller set out in the Guardian what the missing DRM meant for buyers: a title could go onto eight devices, or you could take the plain EPUB and load it onto a Kobo. Amazon listed the books, yet its buy link sent Kindle owners to Pottermore to pay, and Jones called that perhaps the biggest climbdown in Amazon's history.

What the mark holds

In 2012 watermarking was already a service that could be bought. That July the Firsty Group partnered with the Dutch company Icontact for the right to offer its watermarking system, BooXtream, in the UK, as the news list on BooXtream's site records. The same site, headed "Social DRM To The Max", spells out how it works. For each sale the shop sends three things: the customer's name, their email address and the order number. From those, BooXtream adds visible text, all of it optional: a bookplate image with the customer's name on page 2, a personal footer at the end of every chapter, and a disclaimer on the last page with its own entry in the table of contents. It also writes several invisible watermarks into every data file of the EPUB (the post on what's inside an EPUB lists those files), encoding the publisher, the customer and the shop. For Kindle owners it turns the marked EPUB into a Mobi file.

Publishers drop Adobe DRM, 2015 onwards

On 22 June 2015 heise online reported that the German publishers of the Swedish Bonnier group, Piper, Ullstein and Carlsen among them, would replace Adobe DRM with watermarks in their EPUBs on 1 July 2015, and called Bonnier the first large publishing house to make the switch. Adobe's DRM, the kind that usually arrives as an ACSM file, lets a book open only on devices signed in with the reader's Adobe ID. Bonnier said it was too complicated for readers and that its own tests had shown that even hard copy protection was easy to get round. The number of illegal downloads, it argued, depended on how much people wanted a title, not on how hard the protection was. Its books would carry an invisible watermark that traced back to the owner, and a page of warnings for what the company called an extra psychological effect. A spokeswoman told heise the next day that the whole list would change, older books too, unless an author or agent objected, and that the watermark was an encrypted transaction number. Bonnier also promised to chase pirated copies online harder than before.

The help pages of the publisher Verso said in November 2026 that books bought on its own website are watermarked and DRM-free: you may put them on any of your devices, but not upload them to websites or file-sharing networks. The same Verso books bought from Amazon, Apple, Barnes & Noble or Google come with those stores' DRM. The page still names Sony too, although Sony's Reader Store closed in the US and Canada in March 2014 and handed its customers to Kobo. Defective by Design's guide to DRM-free ebook sellers notes that the Finnish bookseller Suomalainen Kirjakauppa puts a watermark on the first page of each ebook in place of DRM. More shops of this kind are in the list of DRM-free ebook sellers.

On the reading side, a watermarked book is an ordinary EPUB. Kobo's file formats page says its e-readers support both Adobe DRM and social DRM, and that a social DRM file opens without Adobe Digital Editions, which an Adobe-protected book needs before it can reach the e-reader.