Ratings and reviews with a spoiler flag
Both the rating and the review of a book live on the Review tab of its book screen. Stars go in halves, the review saves itself as you type, and a “Contains spoilers” checkbox flags it. The rating is stored with the read you finished, so a second read gets one of its own; Track rereads explains how.
Rating a book
On the book screen, your rating sits at the right of the panel with your progress, above the words “your rating”. Click it to open the Review tab, where a click on a star sets full stars and ⌥-click sets a half star. “Clear rating” takes the rating away again.
The line under the stars spells it out: “3½ of 5 · half stars with ⌥-click”, or “Not rated · half stars with ⌥-click” before you've chosen.
Writing a review
Type straight into the Review tab. About a second after you stop, Readwyn saves the text, and only if it actually changed. The tab says “Saved as you type” and keeps a word count.
If the review gives the plot away, click “Contains spoilers”. The flag travels with the review when it goes to Goodreads.
Where ratings show up

The list view has a Rating column, and “Sort” can order the library by rating. The Stats screen shows your average rating, and year in review picks out your highest rated book of the year.
Bringing ratings in, and sending them out
The calibre import keeps the ratings and reviews you had there.
A Goodreads sync carries the rating and the review, spoiler flag included. The Review tab says when yours goes next (“Goes to Goodreads with the next Readwyn ⇄ Goodreads sync.”) and when the Goodreads copy last changed: “The Goodreads review was last updated 30 May 2019.”
A Kobo sync copies the rating from whichever side you sync from. Readwyn's half stars convert to the device's stars, and a half star rounds up.
Removing a book
“Remove from library…” takes the review with it. The alert warns you first: “Its files, 14 highlights and your review go too.”