Readwyn 0.1.0

Why a book can be public domain in one country and not another

W. Somerset Maugham's Cakes and Ale came out in 1930, so it entered the US public domain on 1 January 2026 with every other American book of that year. In Britain it stays in copyright until 2036. Maugham died in 1965, and the UK protects a written work for 70 years after the author's death, which is why Duke's Center for the Study of the Public Domain picks the novel as its example of a book free in one country and not another. Each country sets its own term, and the terms don't start from the same event.

The United States counts most older books from the year they came out, not from the author's death. According to the copyright term chart of Cornell University Library, everything published before 1931 is free, and a book published from 1931 to 1977 with a copyright notice is protected for 95 years after publication, as long as the copyright of a book from 1963 or earlier was renewed. It cuts the other way too. A novel published in 1940 by an author who died in 1945 has been free in the UK since 2016, while a renewed US copyright on it runs 95 years, to the end of 2035.

The same Duke page says that, as a general matter, courts have held you to the law of the place where you use the work. That's why the Project Gutenberg licence tells anyone outside the US to check the laws of their own country, and says the foundation makes no claim about a book's status anywhere else. It's also how Germany lost the whole site from 2018 to 2021. A court in Frankfurt ruled for the publisher S. Fischer Verlag in February 2018 over 18 ebooks by Heinrich Mann, Thomas Mann and Alfred Döblin, and Project Gutenberg blocked every German visitor on 28 February 2018, as its own account of the case records. The two sides settled in October 2021. The country-wide block ended, and the settlement keeps the three authors' books blocked in Germany until their German copyright runs out. Heinrich Mann's had already run out at the end of 2020, Thomas Mann's lasted to the end of 2025, and Döblin's lasts until the end of 2027.

A country can also change its term. Canada protected books for the author's life plus 50 years until the 2022 budget law rewrote section 6 of its Copyright Act to make it 70, and an order in council brought the change into force on 30 December 2022. Section 280 of the Budget Implementation Act, 2022, No. 1 says the new term doesn't revive a copyright that had already expired. Authors who died in 1971 or earlier stay free in Canada, Maugham among them (his books lost their Canadian copyright at the end of 2015). Someone who died in 1972 would have joined them two days after the change; their books now wait until 2043.

Sites run under other laws fill some of the gaps. Faded Page offers books that are public domain in Canada and says it follows Canadian copyright law. Project Gutenberg Australia checks status under Australian law only and asks readers elsewhere to check their own before they share its files; its front page says it stopped adding ebooks on 1 January 2025.