Readwyn 0.1.0

Is e-ink easier on your eyes than a tablet?

In a 2013 study, yes: people who read for over an hour on a backlit Kindle Fire HD reported more eye fatigue and blinked less than when they read on an e-ink Kindle Paperwhite or a paper book, and the e-ink reader and paper came out alike. But the evidence is a handful of small studies, and the researchers themselves suggest the difference came from how bright the screen was rather than from e-ink as such.

Light that comes from the page, and light that comes through it

A tablet's LCD makes its own light: a backlight shines through a layer of liquid crystals, which let more or less of it reach you. An E Ink screen has no backlight. Room light falls on black-and-white pigment and bounces back, as it does from a printed page. E Ink's page on the benefits of its displays says the brightness you see depends on the light around you, and adds that users have told it they don't get the eye fatigue of an LCD over long sessions. E Ink gives no measurement for that. In the dark an e-reader needs its front light: LEDs in the sides of the screen whose light, E Ink says, is angled down onto the ink instead of shining through the display towards you.

What the 2013 study measured

Simone Benedetto and four colleagues published E-Readers and Visual Fatigue in PLOS ONE in December 2013. Twelve adults, none of whom had used an e-reader before, each read Maupassant's Bel-Ami in French on all three: the Fire HD, the Paperwhite and a paper copy set in the same type. The sessions were about ten days apart, in a random order, and averaged 73 minutes, under artificial light that measured 54 lux at the reader's forehead.

On a six-item visual fatigue questionnaire, scores rose after the tablet and didn't change significantly after the Paperwhite or the book. Blinks per second were lower on the tablet than on either of the others, and pupils were smaller. A test of flicker sensitivity, which tracks alertness, fell after reading on every device, with no difference between them. Asked which they liked, readers preferred paper to both screens.

The team also measured how bright each page looked. From 60 cm at eye level, the white of the tablet page gave about 28 cd/m², the paper 16 and the Paperwhite 11. The e-ink page was dimmer than the book. The authors suggest the tablet's higher luminance explains both the smaller pupils and the extra fatigue, and they note that a test of particular devices gives results that hold for those devices.

Brightness rather than technology

The same group tested that idea in 2014. In a study in Computers in Human Behavior, 48 people read for an hour on a 22 inch Dell LCD set to either 20 or 140 cd/m², in a room lit at either 5 or 85 lux. Readers blinked less at the brighter setting. Self-rated eye fatigue rose after an hour in every group, though, with no effect of screen brightness or room light at all.

Two years earlier, a Swiss team had found little to choose between the two. Eva Siegenthaler and colleagues had people read for several hours on either e-ink or an LCD and found them very similar on both subjective and objective measures. Those measures ran from self-rated fatigue and a letter search to reading speed, eye movements and the pupil's response to light. Their conclusion: "It is not the technology itself, but rather the image quality" that matters.

Why blinking keeps coming up

The American Academy of Ophthalmology's page on computers and eye strain, dated June 2024, gives a normal rate of about 15 blinks a minute, falling to about 5 to 7 at a screen. It describes the result (dry, stinging or tired eyes, blurred vision) as the same strain that other close work such as reading or sewing brings, and says screens don't permanently damage the eyes. Its advice includes blinking on purpose, looking at something far away from time to time, and matching the screen's brightness to the room.

That's why Benedetto's team counted blinks: their paper links fewer blinks to a poorer tear film and dry eyes. It also notes that people blink less when they read on any medium, and less again on a backlit display, so an e-reader is still close work.

Blue light

Blue light also comes up when people compare a tablet with an e-reader. What it does to sleep is a separate question; the case against it for eye strain is weak. The Academy's 2021 page on blue light says there's no scientific evidence that light from digital devices damages the eye, and it doesn't recommend blue-light glasses for computer use. A Cochrane review published in August 2023, covering 17 trials and 619 adults, found that blue-light filtering lenses may not reduce short-term eye strain from computer work, and rated that evidence low certainty.