Readwyn 0.1.0

Are Guided View and Panel View the same thing for comics?

Partly. Both show a comic one panel at a time, enlarged to fill the screen, in the order the publisher chose, and on a Kindle today they run on the same data. They started out as rivals from two companies: Guided View belonged to comiXology, and Kindle Panel View was Amazon's version of the idea. Amazon has owned comiXology since 2014, and Amazon's publishing guidelines now treat Guided View as an animated layer on top of Panel View markup. Both depend on panel positions that someone marked and stored in the book file. Without them, a Kindle falls back to cutting each page into quarters.

Guided View at comiXology

Iconology Inc., the company behind comiXology, put its Comics app on Apple's App Store on 23 July 2009, for the iPhone and iPod touch, with more than 100 titles from twenty publishers. Its pitch was a guided view that kept each page whole. Some competing apps cut a page into separate pictures that you swiped through as in a photo album.

In November 2010 comiXology opened an invitation-only alpha of its Guided View Authoring Tools, so that publishers and independent creators could mark up the panels of their own books. Tokyopop and Devil's Due were among the first invited. The company's statement, as Bleeding Cool printed it, described reading “full screen or panel-to-panel”, and it called Guided View patent-pending.

Panel View at Amazon

Amazon announced Kindle Panel View as part of Kindle Format 8, alongside the colour Kindle Fire. When Publishers Weekly counted the competing comic formats in November 2011, it read Panel View as Amazon's take on Guided View and noted that Amazon held exclusive Kindle Fire rights to 100 DC graphic novels.

Comics spread beyond the Fire in June 2012, when the Kindle apps for iOS, Android and Cloud Reader gained them, with Panel View on titles that supported it. Creators could mark up their own panels with Kindle Comic Creator, a free tool that Amazon had released by April 2013. It took pages as JPEG, PDF, TIFF, PNG or PPM, suggested where the Panel View regions should go, and handled right-to-left page turns for manga. On E Ink, Nathan Groezinger's review of the second Kindle Paperwhite in November 2013 found Panel View working, though he complained that Amazon's store gave no way to tell which comics had it.

One feature on the Kindle

Amazon announced its purchase of comiXology on 10 April 2014. The press release credited Guided View for the app's place among the ten top grossing iPad apps of 2011 and 2012. Guided View itself arrived in the Kindle app for iOS, Android and Fire tablets with a free update in May 2017. In November 2023 Amazon said that the comiXology app on iOS, Android and Fire OS would stop working on 4 December 2023, when it merged into the Kindle app, and that readers would find their comiXology books there.

What the file holds

A Kindle comic is a fixed-layout book in which each panel is a tap target. Amazon's guide to fixed-layout books with image pop-ups or Virtual Panels gives the markup (November 2026): a div holding a link with the class app-amzn-magnify, whose data-app-amzn-magnify attribute carries a small JSON object. In it, targetId names the enlarged copy of the panel and ordinal gives its place in the reading order. A reader double-taps to enter Panel View. Amazon calls 150% the default and preferred zoom, which needs a page image of 2880 × 1800 pixels; 200% (3840 × 2400) is for small lettering, and 125% (2400 × 1500) only for a very large panel. Capital letters in a pop-up should be at least 2 mm high on a 7 inch screen.

Guided View, in the same guide, adds an animated move from panel to panel with each swipe, panels centred at full screen size, and a custom masking colour around each one. Amazon applies it automatically to compatible comics, using the Panel View code that is already there.

EPUB has its own standard for the same job. EPUB Region-Based Navigation 1.0, which the IDPF made a recommended specification on 26 August 2015, puts the panels in a separate navigation document as a nav element with epub:type="region-based". Each panel is a link to a region of the page, a rectangle given in percentages of the page, or a circle or polygon in pixels or percentages, and a panel can hold nested regions for its speech balloons. A reading system that supports it must step forwards and backwards through the panels in list order, showing each one as large as the screen allows.

A Kindle comic with no publisher panels at all gets Kindle Virtual Panels instead, Amazon's guide says: the Kindle cuts every page into four, in an order taken from the primary-writing-mode setting, which right-to-left manga must give a right-to-left value (horizontal-rl, or vertical-rl for Chinese, Japanese and Korean books). If even one page carries publisher panels, Virtual Panels are switched off for the whole book.