Readwyn 0.1.0

Is dark mode better for reading?

Turn on dark mode in a reading app and the page goes black with pale letters. For readers with normal sight, that page is slightly harder to read accurately than black text on white. Researchers call this the positive polarity advantage, and lab studies keep finding it. It shows up in speed and accuracy, not in how tired people say their eyes feel. A dark page can still make sense for some eyes, and on a phone with an OLED screen it saves battery at high brightness.

What the lab studies found

Dark text on a light background is positive polarity; light text on dark is negative polarity. Much of the research comes from the experimental psychology institute of Heinrich Heine University Düsseldorf. In 2007 Axel Buchner and Nadine Baumgartner had people proofread under both polarities, in a dark room and under office lighting, and dark text on light won both times. Heart rate, breathing, skin conductance, and self-reported eyestrain and fatigue didn't change with the polarity, so neither page took more effort that they could measure.

Older readers were the open question, because light scatters in an ageing lens and that might favour a dark page. The light page still won an acuity test and a proofreading task for younger adults and for older adults alike (Piepenbrock and colleagues, 2013). The younger group was 18 to 33 and the older 60 to 85, according to Nielsen Norman Group's account of the study. A follow-up in Human Factors set the text at 8, 10, 12, and 14 pt, and the light page's lead grew as the type got smaller.

The likely cause is the pupil. A bright page makes it contract, and a smaller pupil gives a sharper image on the retina, as a smaller aperture does in a camera. A 2014 study by the Düsseldorf group measured smaller pupils and better proofreading with the light page.

Many people switch to dark mode at night, and that's where one study found it did worst. Researchers at the MIT AgeLab timed how long people needed to read a word at two type sizes, in near darkness and in light like daylight. Light text on dark in a dark room needed the most time. In bright light, both polarities did well, and so did dark text on light in the dark room. The authors took the result as support for the pupil explanation.

Battery life

A dark page saves power only on a screen whose pixels make their own light. An LCD lights every pixel from a backlight, and an OLED has none. Purdue University researchers measured six popular Android apps, among them Google Maps and YouTube, on the Pixel 2, Pixel 4, Pixel 5, and Moto Z3 in 2021. At 30 to 50% brightness, dark mode saved 3 to 9% of the power on average; at full brightness, 39 to 47%. Indoors, automatic brightness tends to sit at about 30 to 40%, so the usual saving is at the small end.

Eyes that may prefer a dark page

Some readers do better with white on black. Contrast polarity was one of the variables in Gordon Legge's 1985 study of 16 low-vision readers (abstract), and NN/g's summary reports that the seven of them with cloudy ocular media, such as cataracts, read faster with the dark page. Android's developer guide to dark theme also says a dark theme helps people with low vision and people who are sensitive to bright light. The page doesn't have to follow the rest of the app: in Readwyn, the Text panel of the reader sets it to App, Light, or Dark on its own, and another post gives the steps.

Astigmatism can push the other way. All About Vision, in a page reviewed by an optometrist, says people with astigmatism or myopia can see halation, a haze where light letters spread into the black around them, and that it's worse in dark mode.

A small study from the University of Tübingen looked at myopia. Seven adults aged 23 to 29 read for an hour while the researchers measured the choroid, the layer of blood vessels behind the retina. It thinned by about 16 µm with black text on white and thickened by about 10 µm with white on black. Other studies tie a thinner choroid to the development of myopia, so the authors propose that dark text on light may encourage it. The study measured a change over one hour, not myopia itself.