What is controlled digital lending, and why did a court stop it?
On 4 September 2024 a US appeals court ruled that the Internet Archive could not scan in-copyright print books and lend the scans online, even when it lent only one scan for each print copy it kept in storage. That practice is called controlled digital lending, or CDL. A library digitises a book it owns, keeps the print copy out of circulation, and lends the scan to one reader at a time for a fixed period, so the number of copies on loan never exceeds the number it bought or was given. Its supporters argue that this is ordinary library lending in a new format. In Hachette v. Internet Archive, the Second Circuit disagreed: for books that publishers sell or license as ebooks, it held that CDL isn't fair use.
Where the idea came from
The Archive began lending scans through Open Library in June 2010. Its announcement offered two-week loans of books that weren't commercially available, provided nobody else had the copy out, and sent readers to OverDrive for the more than 70,000 current titles that libraries already licensed.
The legal theory came later. A 2018 white paper credits Michelle Wu of Georgetown Law with first exploring it, in a 2011 article in Law Library Journal. In 2018 a group of librarians and lawyers that included Wu and the Archive's policy counsel, Lila Bailey, published the Position Statement on Controlled Digital Lending by Libraries. Its example is a library with three print copies that digitises one: it can lend three scans, or two scans and a print book, but never four copies in total.
The white paper, by David Hansen of Duke and Kyle Courtney of Harvard, sets out the statement's six conditions. The library must have acquired the book lawfully and must own it rather than license it. It can't circulate more copies, in any format, than it owns. Each scan goes to one user at a time, for a loan period like a print loan, and DRM stops readers from copying it. The argument rests on the first-sale doctrine (section 109 of the US Copyright Act, which lets the owner of a copy lend it) and on fair use.
Also in 2018, the Archive started the Open Libraries Project: for each scanned title that a partner library owned and kept out of circulation, the Archive allowed one more loan at a time. According to the court, 62 libraries had joined by December 2021.
The emergency library and the lawsuit
On 24 March 2020, with schools and libraries closed by COVID-19, the Archive opened a National Emergency Library. It dropped the waiting lists on the 1.4 million books in its lending library until 30 June or the end of the US national emergency, whichever came later. The appeal court found that up to 10,000 people could then borrow one scan at once, whatever the number of print copies behind it. The Archive itself called this a departure from CDL.
Hachette, HarperCollins, Wiley, and Penguin Random House sued on 1 June 2020 in the Southern District of New York. The complaint named 127 books, from The Bell Jar to Wind Power for Dummies. Nine days later the Archive said it would close the emergency library on 16 June, two weeks early, and return to "traditional controlled digital lending". The suit carried on, because it challenged ordinary CDL too.
Judge John Koeltl granted summary judgment to the publishers on 24 March 2023, three years to the day after the emergency library opened, and found that all four fair-use factors favoured them. On 11 August 2023 the parties filed a negotiated judgment: a permanent injunction covering the four publishers' whole catalogues of books available as ebooks, not just the 127, and a confidential sum that the Archive would pay only if it lost on appeal.
What the appeal court decided
Judges Menashi, Robinson, and Kahn heard the appeal on 28 June 2024. Their opinion corrected Koeltl on one point. The Archive is a nonprofit and charges nothing for loans, so its use was non-commercial, even with a Donate link on its site and a share of sales made through its links to Better World Books. That didn't rescue it. The scans did the same job as the books and added nothing new, and they competed with the ebook licences that publishers sell to libraries through distributors such as OverDrive. The opinion lists those terms: Hachette sells two-year licences, and HarperCollins sells licences that expire after 26 loans, which is one reason library ebooks have waiting lists.
The court also went back to its own Google Books decision. Snippets in search results were fair use there, but the 2015 ruling had said that authors would have a strong claim against putting whole digitised books before the public, which is what the Archive did. In a footnote it refused the Archive's fallback request to keep lending scans of books it owned itself, outside the partner scheme: the analysis, it said, would not be substantially different.
On 4 December 2024 the Archive announced that it wouldn't ask the Supreme Court to hear the case. Its help page puts the books it can no longer lend at more than 500,000, a count that includes titles pulled at the demand of other publishers in the Association of American Publishers. The Archive had agreed in August 2023 to take down any AAP member's ebook titles by the same process, in return for the association not backing further suits over CDL. The judgment reaches only books that are available as ebooks, and the same post said that out-of-print books would stay on loan, along with interlibrary loan and accessible copies for readers with print disabilities.