The time Amazon deleted 1984 from Kindles
In July 2009 Amazon reached into its customers' Kindles and deleted two George Orwell novels, Nineteen Eighty-Four and Animal Farm, then refunded what people had paid. The story broke on 17 July. Amazon's spokesman, Drew Herdener, told the Guardian that a third party with no rights to the books had added them through Amazon's self-service platform, and that when the rights holder complained, Amazon removed the copies "from our systems and from customers' devices".
The seller was a company called MobileReference. Before Herdener's statement, customer service had told buyers the publisher had pulled the titles, which Engadget reported along with a message saying the books now showed as "not yet available". Orwell died in 1950, so his work was already free of copyright in some countries, though not yet in the US or Europe, the Guardian noted.
Nobody missed the irony. In the novel, inconvenient records vanish down the memory hole, and Amazon had just made a book vanish from devices people thought they owned. On 23 July Jeff Bezos posted an apology on the Kindle forum, calling the company's fix "stupid, thoughtless and painfully out of line with our principles" (The New York Times).
A week later Justin Gawronski, a 17-year-old high school student, sued. He'd been writing notes on his Kindle copy of Nineteen Eighty-Four for a summer assignment, and the deletion left them useless; the suit asked for class-action status and a ban on Amazon getting into Kindles like that again. In September Amazon offered affected buyers a choice: the book delivered again with their notes intact, or a $30 cheque.
Gawronski and a co-plaintiff, Antoine Bruguier, never got to trial. On 25 September 2009 the two sides filed a settlement in the US District Court in Seattle, subject to the court's approval (TechFlash). Amazon agreed to pay $150,000 in fees to the plaintiffs' lawyers, and the lead firm, KamberEdelson, said it would give its share to charity. The more lasting part was a written promise. The Kindle terms of the time granted "the non-exclusive right to keep a permanent copy" of each book, and for books bought under those terms on Kindles used in the US, the stipulation says Amazon wouldn't remotely delete or change them unless the owner agreed, the owner asked for a refund or the payment failed, a court or regulator ordered it, or deletion was needed to protect the user, the device, or the network (harmful code hidden in an ebook, say).
Engadget's Nilay Patel saw the gap in it: a court order would still be enough to pull a book, while no judge can send a bookshop into your house to take back a paper copy. And the promise covered US devices only.
The episode still comes up whenever people ask whether you own your Kindle books. At the time, Cindy Cohn of the Electronic Frontier Foundation told the Guardian that DRM leads buyers to think they've purchased something when, to the seller and often the law, they've got much less. Orwell's books left copyright in the UK on 1 January 2021. In the US, a book published in 1949 with a copyright notice and then renewed is protected for 95 years (Cornell's public-domain chart), so Nineteen Eighty-Four stays protected there until the end of 2044.